Order Gift Cards HERE

OPEN DAILY, SUNDAY- THURSDAY, 7 AM – 9 PM, FRIDAY – SATURDAY, 7 AM – 10 PM | 226 West Bitters Rd., Ste. 126, San Antonio, TX 78216

Order Online
Download Menu
Order Online
Download Menu

Dessert

Satisfy your sweet tooth with our decadent Dessert Menu, featuring a variety of classic treats that will transport you back to the heart of New York. From creamy milkshakes to indulgent sundaes, every dessert is made to delight both kids and adults alike.

All American
15.95

Apple crumb pie, vanilla milkshake, vanilla frosting, pie crust crumbles, pretzel rods, whipped cream and caramel drizzle.
Apple Crumb Pie
9.95

Sold by the slice. À la mode +2.95.
Babka
5.95

A rich sweet bread braided with chocolate or cinnamon.
Banana Split
12.95

Neapolitan ice cream, chocolate sauce, strawberry sauce, caramel, pecans, sprinkles, and banana.
Black & White Milkshake
9.95

Vanilla ice cream with chocolate syrup.
Bowl of Ice Cream
7.95

One (1) large scoop of your favorite flavor, one (1) topping, whipped cream and a maraschino cherry.
Carrot Cake
9.95

Moist carrot cake, traditional cream cheese frosting and chopped walnuts.
Cheesecake of the Month
12.95

Ask your server this months special.
Chocolate Ding Dong Cake
12.95

A giant moist chocolate layer cake with cream filling.
Chocolate Espresso Cake
9.95

Sold by the slice. Chocolate cake, fudge filling, espresso-infused frosting.
Coke Float
6.95

Coca Cola and scoops of ice cream.
Confetti Cake
12.95

Sold by the slice. A giant seven-layer confetti cake with layers of beautiful rainbow frosting.
Cookie Monster
15.95

Giant chocolate chip cookie, vanilla milkshake, vanilla frosting, dark and white chocolate chips, whipped cream and chocolate drizzle.
Double Chocolate Supreme
15.95

Giant double chocolate cookie, chocolate milkshake, chocolate frosting, white chocolate chips, pretzel rods, whipped cream, chocolate drizzle.
Drew’s Famous Banana Pudding
12.95

Homemade pastry cream, fresh bananas, Nilla wafers and toasted Italian meringue.
Eclair / Cream Puff
12.95

Homemade choux pastry filled and dipped.
Floats
9.95

Choice of Coca Cola, Dr. Pepper or Root Beer topped with vanilla, chocolate or strawberry Ice Cream.
Giant Cookies
4.95

Black & White, Linzer Tart, Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, Peanut Butter, Double Chocolate Chip.
Handspun Diner Milkshakes
9.95

Choose from Melvin's Homemade vanilla, chocolate, strawberry and coffee ice cream
Italian Cream Cake
9.95

Sold by the slice. Layers of white cake, Italian pastry cream, toasted almonds, and coconut.
Key Lime Pie Parfait
7.95

Our tart key lime filling over a graham cracker granola crumble and topped with whipped cream.
Memphis Mafia Shake
10.95

Bananas, peanut butter and vanilla ice cream.
New York Cheesecake
11.95

Takes you back to Broadway!
New York, New York
15.95

Giant black & white cookie, chocolate shake, chocolate frosting, white chocolate chips, pretzel rods, peanut butter cups, whipped cream, chocolate drizzle.
Oreo Crumble Milkshake
9.95

Melvin's Vanilla or chocolate ice cream and Oreo cookies.
Rugelach
4.95

(3) Bite-sized sweet pastries filled with fruit jam, chocolate or cinnamon.
Strawberry Layer Cake
9.95

Sold by the slice. Layers of delicious strawberry cake and strawberry cream.
Sundae Best
9.95

Two (2) scoops, two (2) toppings, whipped cream and a maraschino cherry.
The Birthday Cake
15.95

Birthday cupcake atop your favorite milkshake flavor, vanilla frosting, rainbow sprinkles, whipped cream, pretzel rods and a birthday candle.
The Memphis Mafia
10.95

Bananas, peanut butter and Melvin's vanilla ice cream.
Main Menu
See You Soon!
  • © 2025 Max & Louie’s New York Diner. All Rights Reserved.
Scroll to Top